Department of commerce, national institute of standards and technology. In addition to showing that the object introduced in evidence is the same object as the one involved in the crime, the proponent of the evidence. The documentation of evidence is key for maintaining a chain of custody because everything that is done to the piece of evidence must be listed and whoever came in contact with that piece of evidence is accountable for what. The chain of custody is the roadmap for the evidence gathered in a criminal case. Criminal law chain of custody the state has provided sufficient evidence to show that there is a reasonable probability that no tampering occurred. For the evidence to be of use in a trial, it must make the journey from crime scene to court in a validated and secure manner so that all involved can be assured that it has not been contaminated and that the evidence is relevant to the crime investigation. Maintaining a chain of custody is essential for the forensic scientist that is working on a specific criminal case. The chain of custody requirement has two objectives. During the process, several people typically handle the evidence, logging it out and logging it in and physically signing forms to complete the process. Section 301 the roles of police officers and coroners. Apr 11, 2012 chain of custody in a criminal case according to n. The chain of custody and property release form are divided into three parts.
Submission to lab evidence should be submitted along with the following. The text includes a description of the trial process, types of evidence, the rules relating to relevance, hearsay including the confrontation clause, documentary evidence, qualification of witnesses, privileges, presumptions, judicial notice, photographs, and. This is the chain of custody, and its especially important when exhibits have been altered in some way or tested prior to trial. The chain of custody in digital forensics can also be referred to as the forensic link, the paper trail, or the chronological documentation of electronic evidence. Judges in bench trials and jurors in jury trials are obligated to decide cases on the evidence that is presented to them in court. Chain of custody in a criminal case legal guides avvo. Does continuity have to be proved from hand to hand. A primary means of authenticating an item involves analyzing the chain of custody for evidence. Chain of custody legal definition of chain of custody. Chain of custody is essentially documenting the way that we secure, transport and verify that items acquired for investigation were held in an appropriate manner. Quick reference guide to introducing evidence preserving the record for appeal remember to preserve the record. Malone is accused of murder and the evidence against him is convincing. The las vegas chain of custody refers to the foundation that the prosecution needs in order to establish that certain types of evidence can be admitted at trial. Today, the chain of custody is the process of handling evidence from the time it is collected until the time it is presented as evidence in a court of law.
The chain of custody is important to the investigation process because it is the first step when authenticating digital audio and video evidence. Although this is a common plot in legal thrillers, levy does a good job of raising this novel a few notches above the ordinary. Ensure that true exemplar samples and pseudoexemplar samples are. Chain of custody coc, in legal contexts, is the chronological documentation or paper trail that records the sequence of custody, control, transfer, analysis, and disposition of physical or electronic evidence. The opinions, factual and other findings, conclusions, or recommendations in this publication represent the points of. White paper y d o t s u authenticating digital c evidence. The movement and location of physical evidence from the time it is obtained until the time it is presented in court. Chain of custody is defined as the documentation of the history of samples through all. March 2018 as part of the priority criminal justice needs initiative. Collection techniques, preservation, packaging, transportation, storage and creation of the inventory list are all part of the process used in establishing the chain of.
The first is to lay a proper foundation connecting the evidence to the accused or to a place or object that is relevant to the case. Chain of custody documentation serves three main purposes. Electronic evidence an overview sciencedirect topics. How to maintain the chain of custody for mobile forensic evidence. Pdf improving chain of custody in forensic investigation of. Chain of custody is a legal term referring to the order and manner in which physical or electronic evidence in criminal and civil investigations has been handled. Chain of custody definition, examples, cases, processes. Improving chain of custody in forensic investigation of electronic digital systems. Chain of custody for evidence using blockchain technology. In chain of custody, harold levy describes the plight of michael malone, a cardiologist turned highpowered lawyer. Dna for the defense bar j u n e 2 0 1 2 national institute of justice this document is not intended to create, and may not be relied upon to party in any matter civil or criminal. You know there has to be a continued, reliable way to show the evidence collected at the crime scene is the same evidence that is being.
Creating and maintaining a chain of custody means that a detailed log is kept of. In a las vegas criminal case, you may hear the phrase chain of custody used to describe evidence. Best practices manual for evidence collection, handling, storage, and retention in massachusetts contributors authors. Make sure excluded evidence has been marked for identification and make an offer of proof of what the evidence would be, why it is relevant, and why it is admissible. Due to the nature of digital evidence collection, we will need to discuss a couple of special considerations, as well. Zinnikas, fbinyojttf chain of custody is the ability to give an accurate accounting in a court of law as to the manner in which evidence was acquired, maintained, transported, examined, etc.
Chain of custody forms should also include signatures of individuals who were in possession of the evidence and the dates of transfer. Digital chain of custody is the record of preservation of digital evidence from collection to presentation in the court of law. In all chain of custody examples, the judge can rule the evidence inadmissible. Page 5 of 39 published for home office staff on 27 november 2019 definition of evidence this section tells criminal investigators in immigration enforcement ie and suitably trained and accredited criminal investigators within the home office about the. Similarly, if the condition of an object, not merely its identity, is relevant, a chain of custody may be required to establish that the condition of the ob ject had not been altered during police custody. The purpose of testimony concerning chain of custody is to prove that evidence has not been altered or changed from the time it was collected through production in court. The law requires the police to be able to track where the evidence went once it was collected at the scene, that is, maintain a documented chain of custody or paper trail. Investigators are usually diligent in ensuring the chain of custody for the device and make sure. Continuity evidence in criminal cases a somewhat defence perspective introduction when i think of continuity evidence also known as chain of custody evidence i actually think of questions. Chain of custody describes a process as testified to by an. This form covers the key needs of most chain of custody cases. Chain of custody is important for electronic evidence because it can be easily altered.
Some agencies use one form to describe the property evidence and to document the chain of custody and property disposition details. The chain of custody rule is a variation of the requirement under fed. Importance of the chain of custody for digital media. Evidence, chain of custody evidence found at the scene of a crime must eventually be presented and questioned in the courtroom. Do not handle the evidence in any way prior to contacting a certified responder unless its to secure an area or lives are in danger. For the purpose of establishing, in a criminal or civil proceeding, the chain of physical custody or control of evidence consisting of or containing a substance tested or analyzed to determine whether it is a controlled substance defined under chapter 47 of title 16, a statement signed by each successive person in the chain of custody that the. Rather, the statutes encourage the goal of maintaining the integrity of the evidence, which is satisfied when the state presents.
Depending on the circumstances of the case, a chain of custody foundation will assist in the admission of evidence. Opinions or points of view expressed in this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official position of the u. Of particular importance in criminal cases, the concept is also applied in civil litigationand sometimes more broadly in drug testing of athletes, and in supply chain management, e. For law enforcement or other agencies desiring to submit evidence to the tarrant county medical examiners. Digital forensics the essential chain of custody the. Case western reserve university school of law scholarly commons. Identifying this chain of custody provides information about whether or not this evidence has been copied or cloned. Continuity evidence in criminal cases a somewhat defence. Proper chain of custody does not just include the chronological order of the custody of a particular piece of evidence. Criminal law evidence establishing chain of custody the court of appeals held that courts and judicial proceedings article 101001, 101002, and 101003 do not require strict application. Submit samples for psa testing, amylase testing, andor dna extraction as needed. The dna test results of biological material on a napkin kept by the victim were determined to be consistent with petitioners. Disturbing breaks in evidence chain of custody orange. Standard operating procedure 620 chain of custody procedures.
Practice, criminal procedure by honorable leonard arnoldretired, j. Chain of custodyrecommendations for acceptance and analysis. What is the chain of custody in computer forensics. Chain of custody in computer forensics infosec resources. The chain of custody is the most critical process of evidence documentation. Dec, 2015 youve heard of the chain of custody in a criminal case. Properly filled out submission form with completed chain of custody. Chain of custody demonstrates trust to the courts and to client that the media was not tampered with. Some agencies include this information on the property evidence report. Evidence can be thrown out at court if it not handled properly. Failure to store items correctly could seriously degrade the substance, and thus lead to a break in the chain of custody. The texas department of public safety dps provides high quality forensic testing on evidence associated with a criminal investigation for any law enforcement agency in texas.
A chain of custody is necessary if there is any possibility that litigants will use analytical data or conclusions based upon that data in litigation. Commonly, forensic evidence collected surgically is sent to the pathology department as a biological specimen. An accurate chain of custody identifies and tracks the evidence from the time it was collectedincluding the method by which it was obtainedthrough final. The identification portion contains the date, time and location of the event. Backup chain of custody sample storage devices 16 computer security for chain of custody 17 references 17 appendix 1.
The seventh edition of criminal evidence presents the basic concepts of criminal evidence applied in the criminal justice environment. Case western reserve university school of law scholarly. The time, place and circumstances of taking possession of the object the object was safely kept while in the witnesss possession the time, place and circumstances of how the object was disposed of the exhibit looks like the object. The second purpose of the chain of custody for physical evidence is to ensure that the object is what its proponent claims it to be. Technical working group on biological evidence preservation. This book is intended to provide a structure and a starting point for those who are coming for the first time or after an absence to the law of evidence, as it applies in criminal proceedings, or for those who want to know more about how the act has changed the rules they learnt during their law degree.
The evidence management module records changes in the location, status, and custodian of evidence items. Chain of custody and property release form has been developed for tracking physical evidence collected at crime scenes. The term chain of custody refers to the protocol for handling physical proof that will be introduced in a courtroom, ensuring evidence complies with the rules of criminal procedure. Bullets, in particular, are pieces of evidence that can be altered by pathology procedures, and many times, the proper chain of custody is not maintained during the process.
The chain of custody form may also include the reason for collection, relevant serial numbers, a physical description of the collected item, and method of capture. In criminal trials, the prosecution must typically prove that all evidence was handled according to a properly documented and unbroken chain of custody. Offcampus, use your library number to access online resources. Obtain the evidence from the evidence storage area and complete the chain of custody. Maintaining the chain of custody evidence handling in. The importance of chain of custody for legal proceedings. Once the evidence is collected, it must be accounted for in documents literally during every stage of the investigation. This chapter describes the components of a chain of custody and the procedures for the use. Scene or evidence photos that may be beneficial to analysis.
When there is a chance of confusion, or that data may have been altered or tampered with, evidence establishing a chain of custody is important. Is chain of evidence and chain of custody the same thing. Chain of custody is an essential firststep in cyber forensics investigations. The dna test results of biological material on a napkin kept by the victim were determined. Maintaining the chain of custody for mobile forensic evidence. Pdf digital chain of custody is the record of preservation of digital evidence from collection to presentation in the court of law. Section 301 the roles of police officers and coroners physical evidence is not subject to subjective analysis coroners and law enforcement officers are aware of criminal cases involving real, or alleged, mental incompetence or insanity on the part of the suspectdefendant. Standard operating procedure 620 chain of custody procedures purpose the purpose of following chain of custody procedures is to maintain the quality of all samples during collection, transportation, and storage prior to analysis. Chain of custody chain of evidence statpearls ncbi. Shortened version of chain of custody policies 20 acknowledgments 26.
The chain of custody is a tracking record beginning with detailed scene notes that describe where the evidence was received or collected. Section 725 ilcs 51164 chain of custody a before or after the trial in a prosecution for a violation of section 111. Record evidence received and track a complete chain of custody the evidence management module simplifies evidence tracking, allowing an agency to maintain a complete and accurate chain of custody for every piece of evidence received. West publishing, volume 32, chapter 21, section 1034,honorable leonard arnold, j. This is an essential part of digital investigation process. As such, it is critically important that criminal defendants are able to ensure that all forms of evidence being presented against them are legitimate. It also encompasses how a particular piece of evidence is collected and stored. The processes for documenting, collecting, and protecting evidence are called establishing a chain of custody.
It is a must to assure the court of law that the evidence is authentic, i. Because criminal prosecutions typically depend on evidence gathered by police officers, it is prosecutors who generally need to establish a chain of custody. In defense against a clients criminal charges, a lawyer may attack the arresting police agencys handling of physical evidence against the defendant. Chain of custody each witness in the chain must establish. Chain of custody refers to the chronological documentation andor paper trail showing the seizure, custody, control, transfer, analysis, and disposition of evidence, physical or electronic. Dna evidence places malone at the bloodsoaked murder scene of his estranged wife, a deputy da who was suing him for custody of their only child.
Record evidence received and track a complete chain of custody. This form is used to track the movement of property evidence from the time it is seized until its final disposition. Providing an accurate and complete chain of custody record ensures that the evidence that arrives in court is what was collected at the crime scene. Neither judges nor jurors may conduct their own investigations into the. The essential in digital forensics is chain of custody, which is an attempt to preserve the integrity of digital evidence as well as a procedure for performing documentation chronologically toward. It has been almost six years since daniel wozniak murdered two friends in a disturbing plot to rob one of them to pay for mr. By following the chain of custody, you can see where an item of evidence has been from the moment it was collected to the time it is offered as evidence in a criminal trial. May 15, 2012 the chain of custody is the roadmap for the evidence gathered in a criminal case. Section 725 ilcs 51164 chain of custody, 725 ilcs 5. This refers to the chronological documentation of who handled it, what they did with it, and where they stored it. Basically, there are rules for managing different types of evidence and keeping it reliable, and this is the set that applies to the admissibility of material things. Jul 08, 20 chain of custody is the process that the prosecution is required to prove that the evidence was kept by the custodian without leaving the formal custody in the manner in must be preserved to give credible foundation for the evidence to be sought to be admitted in a hearing or trial. Improving chain of custody in forensic investigation of.
463 218 581 600 1379 615 1591 410 737 223 59 1256 1524 611 1084 1077 1006 1502 214 918 405 727 1251 220 899 589 1563 769 83 1213 745 417 659 950 278 1401 518 1178 696 42 568